Newsletter #11, April 2005

In this issue:

Upcoming events | Waitangi Day at Orongomai Marae | The Chair’s Inclinations: Back to future proofing... | Mangaroa Rural Field Day and Fair | Maymorn Station Building | February walk | Looking back — Auckland express near Kaitoke | Contacts | Electronic Copy

Waimate station, platform side.

The Rimutaka Incline Railway Heritage Trust is planning to construct at Maymorn an accurate replica of the former Waimate station building — designed by George Troup. It will include an information and discovery centre as well as making ample provision for future visitor numbers. The east end of Waimate station building is seen here on the last day of operation of the Waimate Branch — 31 March 1966. The Trust proposes to replicate this station at Maymorn. Photo: Colin Dash

Upcoming events

Sunday 1st May formation walk
We plan to walk a substantial portion of the heritage route, from Kaitoke to Summit and return. Meet at 9 am at Kaitoke car park, Incline Road, off State Highway Two approximately 6km north of Upper Hutt. Bring lunch, water, raincoat, stout shoes and warm clothes. RSVP to Hugh McCracken;

email: hugh.mccracken@rimutaka-incline-railway.org.nz

Wednesday 11 May Members’ night - Maymorn project
The Maymorn rail heritage precinct project will be outlined and explored. Aspects covered will include site maps, facilities, plans for replica station building, locomotive and carriage shed, fencing, platforms, future mainline connection and use of second track formation over the Maymorn Road underpass.

Meet at Level 1 Meeting Room, Upper Hutt City Council. Access is from carpark to rear of building along from H20Extreme. Light refreshments provided.

Sunday 5th June Formation walk - Maymorn to Kaitoke
Meeting at Maymorn station platform at 10:35am, the arrival time of the Sunday morning Wellington - Masterton train (which departs Wellington at 09:55am, Waterloo at 10:14am and Upper Hutt at 10:29am). After viewing the Trust’s proposals in the Maymorn yard, we will walk the heritage railway formation through Mangaroa Tunnel and Tunnel Gully to Kaitoke. RSVP to Hugh McCracken email: hugh.mccracken@rimutaka-incline-railway.org.nz - to ensure that sufficient return transport to Upper Hutt can be organised.

Waitangi Day at Orongomai Marae

Waitangi Day at Orongomai Marae, Trust display to right.

Waitangi Day at Orongomai Marae, Trust display to right (arrowed). A new station signboard for Maymorn formed part of the display.

The Trust welcomed the opportunity to have a display at Orongomai Marae on Saturday 5th February, taking part in the Waitangi Day celebrations. Invited guests represented the Crown, Upper Hutt City Council and a wide range of community organisations and groups.

Trustees were interested to hear firsthand the history of the Marae. Dedication and enthusiasm has borne fruit, as evident in the splendid wharenui, wharekai, medical centre and other facilities.

It was a privilege to have been a part of the day.

The Chair’s Inclinations: Back to future proofing...

As the first step in the reinstatement of the Rimutaka Incline Railway, the Trust is establishing a a railway heritage precinct at Maymorn. The precinct has been carefully thought out so as to provide for future capacity — both on the Rimutaka Incline Railway, and the national railway network.

The Trust wishes to replicate a historic station design by George Troup, and had originally thought that the former Kaiwarra (later renamed Kaiwharawhara) design would be adequate for Maymorn. On review of the range of uses that it would be put to, it became apparent that the 15 x 50 foot (4.5m x 15.2m) design would undersized. A larger 20 x 108 foot (6m x 33m) design was called for.

A short-list of three Troup-designed station buildings was drawn up, including Blenheim, Kaiapoi and Waimate. As detailed elsewhere in this publication, the Waimate design was selected for replication, as it is closest to the Trust’s requirements. This design featured a 20 foot (6m) wide ridged verandah and associated decorative ironwork, twin gabled ends, gabled wings, porches, a bay window and solid decorative features — all of which typified the best of Troup’s design prowess.

new rail being laid at Ngauranga.

The government is again investing in New Zealand’s railway infrastructure.

Reviewing George Troup’s biography provides interesting contextural information about the design. During the first decade of the twentieth Century, New Zealand Government Railways were being upgraded. The depression years of the 1890s had seen a lack of investment, and wagons, carriages and locomotives were antiquated and inadequate for traffic requirements. The railway infrastructure, including station yards and station buildings, were in a similar state, and Troup set about designing modern buildings that could meet forecasted traffic requirements.

Zooming forward to the current day, a similar situation can be seen in the national railway network. Significant investment is being made in railway infrastructure, to catch up with deferred maintenance and to build capacity and capability for the nation’s future requirements.

Making provision for future capacity is not a new phenomenon. The Rimutaka Incline Railway is planning station buildings, platforms, yards, loops and sections between stations to cater for trains up to twelve carriages in length. Four of these trains could be on the system between Upper Hutt and Summit at once.

This is not to say that the starting position of the Trust’s operation would involve such a capacity and capability, but future requirements such as these are being considered right from the outset. The Trust is future-proofing the “sanctuary for steam” for what promises to be the iconic tourist attraction for the Wellington region.

Regards
Hugh McCracken

Trustees discussing the project with visitors to the fair.

Trustees discussing the project with visitors to the Trust’s display at the Mangaroa Rural Field Day and Fair. Photos this section: Hugh McCracken.

Mangaroa Rural Field Day and Fair

The Trust had a display at the Mangaroa Rural Field Day and Fair, held at Mangaroa School on Saturday 19th March. Amongst the days entertainment included novelty races for children, food, horse rides, and helicopter rides (which proved to be very popular).

Fell trackset display at Mangaroa Rural Field Day and Fair.

The Trust’s Fell trackset prominently displayed at the Fair.

The Trust was well received, residents and visitors to Mangaroa showing much interest in the display and plans for the Rimutaka Incline Railway between Upper Hutt and Summit, with initial base at Maymorn.

end elevation of proposed Maymorn station.

End elevation of proposed Maymorn station, based on NZR CCE plan 14144, Waimate station building — dated 1907.

Maymorn Station Building

Requirements

In the June 2004 newsletter the Trust proposed replicating at Maymorn the former Kaiwarra (later renamed Kaiwharawhara) station building, designed by George Troup. Review of requirements has lead the Trust to set its sights on a larger station building so as to better cater for anticipated visitor numbers.

It is anticipated that the station building will be used:

George Troup, 1927.

Seated studio portrait of George Alexander Troup. Photographed by Stanley Polkinghorne Andrew in 1927.

Permission of the Alexander Turnbull Library, National Library of New Zealand Te Puna Matauranga o Aotearoa, must be obtained before any re-use of this image.

In the medium term some of these functions may move to other buildings at Maymorn or elsewhere on the railway. The main functions of the building will then be passenger handling and local train management.

Design Brief

A Design Brief has been prepared, outlining the Trust’s requirements for a station building at Maymorn. The brief is being considered by conservation architects with a view to producing working drawings and specifications suitable for consent application and drafting a construction contract.

George Troup

George Troup was born in Edinburgh on 21 October 1863, educated at Gordon’s College in the same city and completed an architect–surveyors apprenticeship in 1882. He emigrated to New Zealand in 1884, joining New Zealand Railways at Dunedin two years later. Troup transferred to Head Office in Wellington to work as a draughtsman in 1888, and was promoted to the role of Chief Draughtsman in 1892. The late 1890’s saw widespread improvements to the colony’s railway infrastructure, new lines being opened and existing facilities upgraded. Twenty district stations were designed, and final engineering requirements for the North Island Main Trunk were completed, including viaducts, bridges, and stations.

Troup designed two notable buildings, being the 1902 NZR Head Office in Featherston Street, Wellington, and the new Dunedin station in 1906, which is widely regarded as Troup’s finest achievement.

Dunedin station, platform side.

Platform side of Dunedin railway station, 30 May 2003. Toll rail shunt locomotive DSG 3114 passes through on the second loop, with Taieri Gorge Limited carriages stored on the former main line in the background. Photo: Hugh McCracken.

Dunedin station building.

Detail of public side of Dunedin railway station, 30 May 2003. Photo: Hugh McCracken.

Troup travelled to Britain in 1908 to recover from illness exacerbated by the demanding requirements of the previous years. He returned to New Zealand, shifting attention to planning and administrative tasks, including plans for a new station building at Wellington, railway duplication and deviation works. Post World War I he was responsible for all railway buildings, and during these years he oversaw the revision and expansion of the NZR Engineer’s Pocket Book, which included standard plans for many engineering works, and the construction of standard railway houses fabricated at a dedicated sawmill and factory facility at Frankton, Hamilton.

On retirement from New Zealand Railways in 1925, Troup went on to be elected to the Wellington City Council, and immediately gained the chairmanship of the Works Committee. He was elected as Mayor in 1927 and oversaw many improvements to the city’s infrastructure, including a milk treatment plant, the aerodrome, a second tunnel through Mt Victoria, a replacement Kelburn viaduct and council housing. Construction of the National Art Gallery, Dominion Museum and Carillon in Buckle Street was commenced shortly after the end of his second term as Mayor.

George Troup died in 1941, leaving a legacy of engineering and architectural achievements.

A number of stations were designed for important locations throughout much of the country, as detailed in the accompanying diagram below.

Relevance to Maymorn

The Wellington and Masterton Railway received a fair number of ‘Troup Era’ stations, existing structures having become inadequate to service early 19th Century traffic levels. These included:

A replica Troup–designed station would be in keeping with station buildings historically associated with the Wellington and Masterton Railway. All but Kaiwarra station outlasted the Rimutaka Incline, including that surviving at Lower Hutt, which is a registered historic building.

The Trust has the objective to plan, fund and construct appropriate buildings ... to facilitate the construction and operation of the tourist heritage railway, and views a replica Troup design as lending authenticity to the heritage railway experience, and to interpretative displays and educational facilities that are proposed to be contained within.

map of distribution of Troup-designed stations.

Distribution and dates of construction of stations designed by George Troup for New Zealand Government Railways.

Authenticity

The Trust intends that all works are designed and constructed wherever practicable in accordance with the heritage objectives of the Railway. A heritage outcome is desired for all structures in order to enhance the visitor experience and to achieve heritage outcomes for the railway.

Potentially suitable heritage station buildings in the Wellington region are either spoken for, or have been demolished. There is little alternative but to construct a replica station building.

An accurate replica is desired — to achieve an authentic outcome, and it is hoped that replicating an existing design will reduce the amount and extent of new design work required.

Waimate design selected

Each end of the Waimate station-building roof terminated in gables, which were richly decorated with corbels and scrollwork. The street-side of the building incorporated two gabled wings and two gabled dormers. The ladies’ waiting room featured a bay window.

Blenheim station street-side view from south.

Street side of Blenheim station in 2005, as modifed after both it and the Main North Line were relocated to accommodate extensive roading improvements in the centre of town. Note the extension in the right foreground housing public conveniences — in the style of the original structure, but unmistakenly an addition. Photo: Glenn Fitzgerald.

Blenheim

Blenheim station had the following distinguishing features:

  • a gable at the south end of the building with little decoratation
  • 15' wide, plain canterlevered verandah
  • eaves and gables supported on delicate corbels
  • on the street side a single central gabled wing
  • a further gabled wing at the north end, forming a hip roofline
Waimate station, street-side, shortly after opening.

The street side of Waimate station is seen here shortly after opening in 1907. (From a postcard in the C.E. Dash collection.)

Waimate

Waimate station had the following distinguishing features:

  • gables at each end of the building decorated with scrollwork
  • 20' wide, pitched verandah with decorative ironwork at each end
  • eaves and gables supported on large corbels
  • central twin gabled wings on the street side
corbel and facia details under verandah, Kaiapoi station.

Corbel and facia details under verandah, Kaiapoi station. The Waimate design was not dissimilar. Photo: Hugh McCracken

Platform side of Kaiapoi station.

Platform side of Kaiapoi station, note the decorative work about the facia boards above and below the windows. Waimate was similarly adorned. Photo: Hugh McCracken

portion of CCE plan 14144, Waimate station building.

NZR CCE plan 14144, Waimate station building — dated 1907.

Other design features

decorative ironwork at Kaiapoi platform ends.

Decorative ironwork at platform ends — Kaiapoi (pictured) was similar to Waimate. Photo: Hugh McCracken

interior of Kaiapoi station, tower part of former ladies waiting room.

Interior of Kaiapoi station, this being the tower part of the former ladies waiting room. Note extensive use of tongue and groove timbers for both wall and ceiling linings. Photo: Hugh McCracken

main entrance to Blenheim station, bay window to right.

Main entrance to Blenheim station, bay window to right. Photo: Glenn Fitzgerald

corbel under barge board, Blenheim.

Corbel under barge board, Blenheim. Photo: Glenn Fitzgerald

Ab 663 with excursion train at Maymorn.

A taste of things to come at Maymorn — Mainline Steam’s Ab 663 and the Tararua Wanderer passes the future Maymorn station building site (to left), 13 February 2005. Photo: Hugh McCracken.

finial and ridge capping, Blenheim Station.

Finial and ridge capping, Blenheim Station. Photo: Glenn Fitzgerald

February walk - Hutt Valley railway heritage tour

Woburn footbridge.

Pratt truss footbridge at Woburn. Photos this section: Hugh McCracken.

The walk of 6th February involved a tour of railway heritage remnants in the Hutt Valley, including:

underpass between Woburn and Waterloo.

Pedestrian underpass between Woburn and Waterloo.

Lower Hutt station building - detail of tower.

Lower Hutt station building - detail of tower above the main entrance.

pedestrian grade crossing between Waterloo and Epuni.

Pedestrian grade crossing between Waterloo and Epuni.

De 508 running around train at Silverstream Railway.

De 508 running around train at McKirdy station, Silverstream Railway. Brian Dawson on trailing footstep.

Looking back — Auckland express near Kaitoke

Ab class locomotives with diverted Auckland Express near Kaitoke.

Ab class locomotives with diverted No. 626 Auckland Express near Kaitoke on 28 January 1953. A rare event, due to flooding of the Manawatu line near Longburn. 56' carriages made occasional forays onto the Rimutaka Incline when the Manwatu Line was blocked, as well as the Royal Train on 15 January 1954 and test trains run during the previous year.
Photo: Le Cren for New Zealand Railways, Archives New Zealand / Te Rua Mahara o te Kawangatanga Wellington Office: [Archives reference: AAVK W3493 B-3572A]

Contacts

Full contact details may be had on the Trust’s website at www.rimutaka-incline-railway.org.nz/contacts.html

Electronic copy

An electronic copy of this newsletter will be available on the Trust’s website at www.rimutaka-incline-railway.org.nz/member-pages/newsletter-11.html from 1 May 2005. Further copies can be printed, or images viewed in colour (where applicable).

Grateful thanks to Tim McKenzie for assistance with proof-reading the newsletter.
Published 14 April 2005.